Old Therapist, New Blog

Even good advice is not therapy

There's always a good supply of good advice, coming at you from friends, and given to them too. When you say it, you mean it, and you hope they do too. If that's not in doubt, what's happening here?

Lots of tabs open, browsing away the minutes and the hours, thinking "that isn't me," or "I don't agree with this," or "it's all too difficult." When all you wanted was an answer about therapy and advice.

Let's give it what it deserves: respect. They're your friends. They live up close with you, and you've been there for them too, saying it because you care. That exchange matters, and it's worth sitting with, because that's the depth of it: being properly heard by someone who knows you.

But that same closeness, the thing that helps the advice land, is also the reason you're here right now. There's too much skin in the game. It makes them a great friend and, frustratingly, someone who can't fix you.

Because you were never theirs to fix.

You heard them, the advice is sound, your people were right. So why are you still exactly where you were?

You understand your situation. You can present it, argue it, defend it, champion it, all with authority. Not knowing was never what kept you stuck. Sometimes advice does close a real gap. Sometimes it's telling you a thing you genuinely didn't know, and that helps. But that's not the gap you're sitting in, right now.

Not a better answer. You've had those. Something that works differently.

The difference between knowing something and being able to do it

So the reason you're here, reading the minutes away, isn't that you haven't tried, or that you dwell, or that there's a lazy streak in you somewhere. It's the distance between knowing something and being able to do something about it. Advice, even good advice, has nothing to say to that distance. It speaks to the part of you that already knows. It has nothing for the part that can't.

So what does?

The gap you felt before, between knowing and doing, turns up again here, but this time it's between two people in a room. It doesn't arrive with a note saying it has an appointment. It comes subtly, repeatedly, in the space between the words, each sentence and paragraph, until it's heard. And that is the work.

Not mind the gap. Close the gap.

How it arrives is anyone's guess. A rush-hour tube, everything at once with no room to breathe. Or a Sunday replacement bus, slow and diverted, three times as long as it should be. Either way it's delivered to me (or I hear the announcement) in the gaps, while we try to make sense of it together. It's a particular kind of listening, and a particular kind of relationship.

Which is also why it isn't for every problem. When the well runs dry, you need someone who knows the ground and where the water went. A water diviner, a geologist, a well driller, a hydrogeologist. But when you already know the answer and still can't move, when the advice was right and it didn't help, that's not a sign you've run out of options.

It's a sign you've reached the edge of what advice is able to do for you.

The advice, the understanding of your situation, the gaps, all of it led you to your edge. And edges are where we can decide to change.

The view from there is something else. Or it's terrifying. Either way, it tends to be where things start.

No more advice to hear. It's slower than that: room for the part that's never been given any, with someone whose only job is to help you get to it.

You don't have to know whether that's for you. You couldn't know yet. But you're already further in than the tabs and the good intentions suggest. You've been circling this for a while, and the circling is not nothing.

It's the edge of the old with a view of the new. It might just be the beginning of something.

Daniel Esparraguera, MBACP (Reg. 387205) is a BACP-registered integrative counsellor with twenty years of practice. He works online and in person near Peckham Rye, South London. More about Daniel →

Verify registration on BACP Register →

← All posts